Article Information

SOROKIN, PARSONS AND HARVARD: RIVALRY, STATUS REVERSAL AND STRATIFICATION IN SCIENCE

Lawrence T. Nichols (ltnichols@retiree.wvu.edu)

West Virginia University, Newington, United States

Citation: Nichols L.T. (2022) Sorokin, Parsons and Harvard: Rivalry, Status Reversal and Stratification in Science. Zhurnal sotsiologii i sotsialnoy antropologii [The Journal of Sociology and Social Anthropology], 25(1): 7–51. https://doi.org/10.31119/jssa.2022.25.1.1

Abstract. The paper examines the lengthy, complex and sometimes conflicted professional and personal relationship between Pitirim A. Sorokin and Talcott Parsons, approaching them as representatives of consecutive generations in social science.  Two of the most prominent and influential U.S. sociologists of the twentieth century, they held simultaneous appointments for some thirty years at Harvard University, where they competed for leadership both at the organizational level and in the field of sociology more generally. The treatment combines narrative with conceptual analysis, by setting out a series of events that have not been fully documented previously and considering them within a broad framework in terms of several phases. The paper emphasizes Harvard as a context, including its organizational culture and prevalent understandings of science, as well as key decision makers and influential figures there who acted in support of, or in opposition to, the careers of Sorokin and Parsons.  The analysis has implications for understanding processes of stratification over time in sociology and other sciences, especially at the organizational level.

Keywords: intergenerational relations, stratification in science, Pitirim A. Sorokin, Talcott Parsons, Harvard University

References

The following abbreviations are used:

FASP: Correspondence of the Dean of the Faculty of Arts and Sciences, Harvard University Archives, Pusey Library

HPP: Correspondence of the President of Harvard University, Harvard University Archives, Pusey Library

LJHP: Faculty Papers of Lawrence J. Henderson, Baker Library, Harvard Graduate School of Business Administration.

RKMP: Faculty Papers of Robert K. Merton, Butler Library, Columbia University.

TPP: Faculty Papers of Talcott Parsons, Harvard University Archives, Pusey Library.

RDS: Records of the Department of Sociology, Harvard University Archives, Pusey Library

Abbott A. (2001) Chaos of disciplines. University of Chicago.

Allen P. (ed.) (1963) Pitirim A. Sorokin in review. Duke University press.

Allport Committee (1943) Letter to Dean P. H. Buck, 11 June.  In: TPP, folder, “Allport Committee.”

Barber B. (ed.) (1970) L.J. Henderson on the social system. University of Chicago Press.

Becker H.P. (1952) Review of The social system. Social Forces, 30(4): 462-465.

Bierstedt R. (1938) Is homo sapient? Saturday Review of Literature. 12 March, 18-19.

Black J.D. (1939) Letter to L. J. Henderson, February 27. In: LJHP.

Brinton C. (1937) Socio-Astrology. Southern Review, 3: 243-266.

Brinton C. (1939) What’s the matter with sociology? Saturday Review of Literature, 20(3): 4-14.

Brinton C. (ed.) (1959) The society of fellows. Harvard University Press.

Buck P.H. (1937) The road to reunion, 1865-1900. Little, Brown.

Buck P.H. (1943) Letter to Professors Allport, Kluckhohn, Mowrer, Murray, and Parsons, June 11th.  In: TPP.

Burbank H.H. (1931) Letter to Dean C.H. Moore, April 16.  In: FASP.

Buxton W. (1998) Snakes and ladders: Parsons and Sorokin at Harvard. In: Ford J., Richard M., Talbutt P. (eds.) Sorokin and civilization: A centennial assessment. Transaction: 31-43.

Buxton W., Nichols L.T. (2000) Talcott Parsons and the “far east” at Harvard, 1941-48: Comparative institutions and national policy. The American Sociologist, 31(1): 5-17.

Buxton W., Turner S. (1992) From education to expertise: Sociology as a “profession.” In: Halliday T.C., Janowitz M. (eds.) Sociology and its publics: The forms and fates of disciplinary organization. University of Chicago Press: 373-407.

Buxton W.J. (1989) From the ‘missing fragment’ to the ‘lost manuscript’: Reflections on Parsons’s engagement with Simmel. The American Sociologist, 29(2): 57-76.

Camic C. (1989) Structure after fifty years: The anatomy of a charter. American Journal of Sociology, 95: 38-107.

Cannon W.B. (1943) Biographical memoir of Lawrence Joseph Henderson, 1878-1942. National Academy of Sciences.

Catlin G. (1939) Reviewed works: The Structure of social action by Talcott Parsons; Bio-Politics by Morley Roberts. Political Science Quarterly, 54(2) (June): 264-266.

Church R.L. (1965) The Economists Study Society. In: Buck P.H. (ed.) The Social Sciences at Harvard, 1860-1920. Harvard University Press.

Deegan M.J. (1988) Jane Addams and the Men of the Chicago School, 1892-1918. Transaction Publishers.

Faris E. (1953) Review of The social system. American Sociological Review, 18(1): 103-106.

Fine G.A. (ed.) (1995) A second Chicago school? The development of a postwar American sociology. University of Chicago Press.

Ford J. (1930) Social Ethics. In: Morison S.E. (ed.) The Development of Harvard University Since the Inauguration of President Eliot, 1869-1929. Harvard University Press.

Fox R. (1997) Talcott Parsons, my teacher. The American Scholar, 66(3): 395-410.

Gerhardt U. (2002) Talcott Parsons: An Intellectual Biography. Cambridge University Press.

Gettys W.E. (1938) Review of the structure of social action. Social Forces, 17: 425-428.

Gould M. (2021) Working through contradictions: Parsons and the Harvard intellectual community. The American Sociologist, 52(1): 38-62.

Harvard Crimson (1951) Parsons calls Sorokin controversy on book similarities oversight. The Harvard Crimson (December 13): 1. 

Harvard Crimson (1951) Sorokin hits Parsons’ new volume. The Harvard Crimson (December 12): 1-2.

Harvard Department of Sociology (1937) Resolution in support of the promotion of Talcott Parsons.  In: RDS.

Harvard University (1937) Report of the president and treasurer of Harvard University. Harvard University Press.

Henderson L.H. (1935d) Physician and patient as a social system. New England Journal of Medicine, 212: 819-823.

Henderson L.J. (1932) An approximate definition of fact. California Publications in Philosophy, 14: 179-199.

Henderson L.J. (1935a) Letter to Dean George Birkhoff, December 11.  In: LJHP, Folder, “Birkhoff, Geo.”

Henderson L.J. (1935b) Letter to Allen Moe, Guggenheim Memorial Foundation, ca. December 12.  In: LJHP, “Talcott Parsons.”

Henderson L.J. (1935c) Pareto’s general sociology: A physiologist’s interpretation. Harvard University Press.

Henderson L.J. (1937) Letter to President J. B. Conant, May 21.  In: LJHP, Folder, “Talcott Parsons.”

Heyl B.S. (1968) The Harvard “Pareto circle.” Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences, 4(4): 316-334.

Holmwood J. (1996) Founding sociology? Talcott Parsons and the idea of general theory. Routledge.

Homans G.C., Bailey O.T. (1948) The society of fellows, 1933-1947. Harvard University Press.

Horton D. (1956) Review of Fads and foibles in modern sociology. American Journal of Sociology, 62: 338-339.

House F. (1939) Review of the structure of social action. American Journal of Sociology, 45(1) (July): 129-130.

Howey C. (1984) Jessie Bernard at eighty: Reflections on life and sociology. ASA Footnotes, (May): 6.

Isaac J. (2012) Working knowledge: Making the human sciences from Parsons to Kuhn. Harvard University Press.

Jeffries V. (1999) The Integral Paradigm: The Truth of Faith and the Social Sciences. The American Sociologist, 30(1): 36-55.

Johnston B.V. (1986) Sorokin and Parsons at Harvard: Institutional conflict and the origin of a hegemonic tradition. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences, 22(April): 107-127.

Johnston B.V. (1987) Pitirim Sorokin and the American sociological association: The politics of a professional society. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences, 23(2): 103-133.

Johnston B.V. (1995) Pitirim A, Sorokin: An intellectual biography. University Press of Kansas.

Johnston B.V. (1998) The contemporary crisis and the social relations department at Harvard: A case study in hegemony and disintegration. The American Sociologist, 29(3): 26-42.

Johnston B.V. (1999) Pitirim A. Sorokin on order, change and the reconstruction of society: An integral perspective. Comparative Civilizations Review, 41(4): 25-41.

Johnston B.V., Mandelbaum N.Y., Pokrovsky N. (1994) Commentary on some of the Russian writings of Pitirim A. Sorokin. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences, 30: 28-42.

Lengermann P.M., Niebrugge-Brantley J. (2002) Back to the Future: Settlement House Sociology, 1885-1930. The American Sociologist, 35(1): 5-20.

Lidz V. (2021) Politics and the academic social scientist: The record of Talcott Parsons. The American Sociologist, 52(1): 63-87.

Loubser J.J., Baum R.C., Effrat A., Lidz V.M. (eds.) (1976) Explorations in general theory in social science: Essays in honor of Talcott Parsons. Free Press.

Lynn Smith T. (1983) Obituary: The life and works of Carle C. Zimmerman. International Journal of Sociology of the Family, 13(2): 119-125.

MacIver R.M. (1932) Letter to T. Parsons, October 18. In: TPP, “Correspondence and related papers 1923-1940,” Box 2, Folder, “Correspondence 1931-1932.”

MacLean V.M., Williams J.E. (2012) ’Ghosts of Sociologies Past’: Settlement Sociology in the Progressive Era at the Chicago School of Civics and Philanthropy. The American Sociologist, 43(2): 235-263.

Merton R.K. (1936) The unanticipated consequences of purposive social action. American Sociological Review, 1(6)(December): 894-904.

Merton R.K. (1938a) Science, technology and society in seventeenth century England.  Osiris, 4, Part 2: 360-632.

Merton R.K. (1938b) Social structure and anomie. American Sociological Review, 3(5) (October): 672-682.

Merton R.K. (1948) Discussion of Talcott Parsons’ “The position of sociological theory.” American Sociological Review, 12(April): 165-166.

Merton R.K. (1949) Social theory and social structure. Free Press.

Merton R.K. (1957a) Letter to P. A. Sorokin, October 22. In: RKMP, Series II.1, Box 361, Folder 8.

Merton R.K. (1957b) Priorities in Scientific Discovery: A Chapter in the Sociology of Science. American Sociological Review, 22(6) (December): 635-659.

Merton R.K. (1959) Letter to Talcott Parsons, April 17. In: RKMP.

Merton R.K. (1973) The sociology of science: Theoretical and empirical investigations. Edited and with an introduction by N.W. Storer. University of Chicago Press.

Merton R.K. (1976) Sociological ambivalence and other essays. Free Press.

Merton R.K. (1980) Remembering the young Talcott Parsons. The American Sociologist, 15(May): 68-71.

Merton R.K. (1985) George Sarton: Episodic Recollections by an Unruly Apprentice. Isis, 76(4): 470-486.

Merton R.K. (1994) A life of learning: The Charles Homer Haskins lecture, ACLS Occasional Paper 25. American Council of Learned Societies.

Merton R.K. (1996) The Sorokin-Merton correspondence on “Puritanism, Pietism and science, 1933-34. In: Ford J., Richard M., Talbutt P. (eds.) Sorokin and civilization: A centennial assessment. Transaction Publishers: 21-28.

Merton R.K., Barber B. (1963) Sorokin’s formulations in the sociology of science. In: Allen P. (ed.) Pitirim A. Sorokin in review. Duke University Press: 332-368.

Moore C.H. (1931)  Letter to E. F. Gay, May 29.  In: FASP.

Mullins N.C. (1973) Theory and theory groups in contemporary American sociology. Harper.

Murdock K.B. (1932) Letter to P. A. Sorokin, December 16. In: FASP.

Nichols L.T. (1989) Deviance and social science: The instructive case of Pitirim Sorokin. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences, 25(4): 335-355.

Nichols L.T. (1992) The establishment of sociology at Harvard: A case of organizational ambivalence and scientific vulnerability. In: Elliott C.A., Rossiter M.W. (eds.) Science at Harvard University: Historical perspectives. Lehigh University Press: 191-222.

Nichols L.T. (1996) Intergenerational solidarity in the creation of science: The Ross-Sorokin correspondence, 1921-1931. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences, 32(2): 135-150.

Nichols L.T. (1997) Sociology in the Women’s Annex: Inequality and Integration at Harvard and Radcliffe, 1879-1947. The American Sociologist, 28(1): 5-28.

Nichols L.T. (1998) Social relations undone: Disciplinary divergence and departmental politics at Harvard, 1946-1970. The American Sociologist, 29(2): 191-222.

Nichols L.T. (1999) Science, politics and moral activism: Sorokin’s integralism reconsidered,” Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences, 35(2): 139-155.

Nichols L.T. (2001) Parsons and Simmel at Harvard: Scientific paradigms and organizational culture. In: Trevino A.J. (ed.) Talcott Parsons today: His theory and legacy in contemporary sociology. Rowman and Littlefield: 1-28.

Nichols L.T. (2006) The rise of Homans at Harvard: Pareto and the English villagers.  In: Trevino A.J. (ed.) George C. Homans: History, theory and method. Rowman & Littlefield: 43-62.

Nichols L.T. (2010) Merton as Harvard sociologist: Engagement, thematic continuities and institutional linkages. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences, 46(1): 72-95.

Nichols L.T. (2011) The Diversity of Sorokin’s Integralism: Eastern, Western, Christian and non-Christian Variants. In: Del Pozo E. (ed.) Integralism, Altruism and Reconstruction: Essays in Honor of Pitirim A. Sorokin. Universitat de Valencia Press.

Nichols L.T. (2012) Sorokin as lifelong Russian intellectual: The enactment of an historically rooted sensibility. The American Sociologist, 43(4): 374-405.

Nichols L.T. (2019a) The interstitial ascent of Talcott Parsons: Cross-Disciplinary collaboration and careerism at Harvard, 1927-1951. The American Sociologist, 50(4): 563-588.

Nichols L.T. (2019b) Louisa Pinkham Holt, public sociology and racial desegregation. Society, 56, 378-382.

Nichols L.T. (2019c) The Sorokin-Merton relationship: Intergenerational solidarity, rivalry and affectionate ambivalence. Humanity, Culture and Education, 32(2): 144-186.

Nichols L.T. (2022) Backstage with the Parsons circle: Charisma, dialogue and dissent in the formation of a theory school.  In: Trevino A.J., Staubmann H. (eds.) The Routledge international handbook of Talcott Parsons studies. Routledge.

Nicholson I.M. (2003) Inventing Personality: Gordon Allport and the Science of Selfhood. American Psychological Association.

Noble M. (1944) Letter to T. Parsons, May 13.  In: RDS.

Owens B.R. (2010) Producing Parsons’ reputation: Early critiques of Talcott Parsons’ social theory and the making of a caricature. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences, 46(2) (spring): 165-188.

Parsons T. (1933) Vilfredo Pareto.  In: Seligman E. (ed.) Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences, 11: 576-578.

Parsons T. (1934) Letter to P.A. Sorokin, undated, fall.  In: TPP, Box 2, Folder, “Letters to Sorokin, 1935.”

Parsons T. (1935a) Letter to L.J. Henderson, May 16.  In: LJHP, Folder, “Talcott Parsons.”

Parsons T. (1935b) Letter to P.A. Sorokin, ca. late September.  In: TPP, Box 2, Folder, “Letters to Sorokin, 1935.”

Parsons T. (1935c) Sociological elements in economic thought, I: Historical, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 49(3): 414-53.

Parsons T. (1935d) Sociological elements in economic thought, II: The Analytical Factor, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 49(4): 646-667.

Parsons T. (1936) Pareto’s central analytical scheme. Journal of Social Philosophy, 1: 244-262.

Parsons T. (1937) The structure of social action. McGraw-Hill.

Parsons T. (1939a) Letter to C. Brinton, July 11.  In: TPP.

Parsons T. (1939b) Letter to J. B. Conant, September 28.  In: TPP, Folder, “Faculty (Harvard) correspondence, 1938-1940.”

Parsons T. (1940) An analytical approach to the theory of social stratification. American Journal of Sociology, 45(6): 841-862.

Parsons T. (1944) Letter to Dean P. H. Buck, April 3rd.  In: TPP.

Parsons T. (1944) Letter to M. Noble, May 12th.  In: RDS.

Parsons T. (1948) The position of sociological theory.  American Sociological Review, 13(2): 156-164.

Parsons T. (1950)  The prospects of sociological theory. American Sociological Review, 15(3): 3-16

Parsons T. (1951) The social system. Free Press.

Parsons T. (1956) The department and laboratory of social relations: The first decade. Harvard University Press.

Parsons T. (1960) Structure and process in modern societies. Free Press.

Parsons T. (1966) Societies: Evolutionary and comparative perspectives. Prentice Hall.

Parsons T. (1970) On building social systems theory: A personal history. Daedalus (Fall): 826-881.

Parsons T. (2013 [1963]) Christianity and modern industrial society. In: Tiryakian E.A. (ed.) Sociological theory, values and sociocultural change: Essays in Honor of Pitirim A. Sorokin. Transaction Publishers: 33-70.

Parsons T., Shils E.A. (eds.) (1951) Toward a general theory of action. Harvard University Press.

Parsons T., Shils E.A., Naegele K.D., Pitts, J.R. (1961) Theories of Society: Foundations of Modern Sociological Theory. Free Press.

Peabody F.G. (1904) Jesus Christ and the social question: An examination of the teachings of Jesus in relation to some of the problems of modern social life. Macmillan.

Potts D.B. (1965) Social Ethics, 1881-1931: A Study in Academic Activism. In: Buck P.H. (ed.) The Social Sciences at Harvard, 1860-1920. Harvard University Press.

Rhodes C. (2017) Renewal: The Inclusion of Integralism and Moral Values in the Social Sciences. Rowman and Littlefield.

Roethlisberger F.J., Dickson W.J. (1939) Management and the Worker. Harvard University Press.

Schmidt P.L. (2022) The interdisciplinary study of man at Harvard: A history of the Harvard Department of Social Relations, 1946-1972. Rowman and Littlefield.

Sciortino G. (2021) A blueprint for inclusion: Talcott Parsons, the societal community and the future of universalistic solidarities. The American Sociologist, 52(1): 159-177.

Scott J. (2021) The Emerald Guide to Talcott Parsons. Emerald.

Sica A., Turner S.P. (eds.) (2005) The disobedient generation: Social theorists in the sixties. University of Chicago Press.

Sorokin P.A. (1920) A system of sociology. Two volumes. Kolos.

Sorokin P.A. (1931) Sociology as a science. Social Forces, 10(October): 20-27.

Sorokin P.A. (1932)  Letter to dean K. B. Murdoch, December 17.  In: RDS.

Sorokin P.A. (1935) Letter to T. Parsons, November 21st. In: TPP, Folder, “Department, 1935-1936.”

Sorokin P.A. (1937) Social and cultural dynamics, volumes I, II and III. American Book Co.

Sorokin P.A. (1941a) The crisis of our age. Dutton.

Sorokin P.A. (1941b) Declaration of the independence of the social sciences. Social Science 16(July): 221-229.

Sorokin P.A. (1941c) Social and cultural dynamics, volume IV. American Book Co.

Sorokin P.A. (1942) Man and society in calamity. Dutton.

Sorokin P.A. (1944)  Letter to dean P. H. Buck. May12th.  In: FASP.

Sorokin P.A. (1947) Society, culture and personality. Harper.

Sorokin P.A. (1948) The reconstruction of humanity. Beacon Press.

Sorokin P.A. (1950) Altruistic love. Beacon Press.

Sorokin P.A. (1954) The ways and power of love. Beacon Press.

Sorokin P.A. (1956) Fads and foibles in sociology. Regnery.

Sorokin P.A. (1957) Letter to R. K. Merton, November 5.  In: RKMP, Series II.1, Box 361, Folder 8.

Sorokin P.A. (1959b) Studies of the Harvard research center in creative altruism. 3rd ed., Harvard University Press.

Sorokin P.A. (1963) A long journey. College and University Press.

Sorokin P.A. (1965) Sociology of yesterday, today and tomorrow. American Sociological Review, 30(6): 833-843.

Sorokin P.A. (1966) Sociological theories of today. Harper.

Sorokin P.A., Merton R.K. (1935) The course of Arabian intellectual development, 700-1300 A.D. A study in method. Isis, 22(2): 516-524.

Sorokin P.A., Merton R.K. (1937) Social time: A methodological and functional analysis. American Journal of Sociology, 42(5): 615-629.

Sorokin, P.A. (1959a) Social and cultural mobility. Free Press.

Staubmann H. (2021) C. Wright Mills’ The sociological imagination and the construction of Talcott Parsons as a conservative grand theorist. The American Sociologist, 52(1): 178-193.

Tiryakian E.A. (1979) The significance of schools in the development of sociology.  In: Snizek W.E. et al. (eds.) Contemporary issues in theory and research. Greenwood: 211-233.

Tiryakian E.A. (ed.) (1963) Sociological theory, values, and sociocultural change: Essays in honor of Pitirim A. Sorokin. Free Press.

Wearne B.C. (1989) The theory and scholarship of Talcott Parsons to 1951: A Critical Commentary. Cambridge University Press.

Wearne B.C. (1996) The Amherst essays: Talcott Parsons’s initial foray into sociology. The American Sociologist, 27(4): 8-12.

Weber M. (1930) The Protestant ethic and the spirit of capitalism. Translated by T. Parsons. Allen and Unwin.

Whitehead A.N. (1925) Science and the modern world. Macmillan.

Wilson E.B. (1939) Letter to L. J. Henderson, February 23.  In: LJHP, Folder, “Wilson, E.B.”

Wirth L. (1939) Review of the structure of social action. American Sociological Review, 4(3): 399-404.

Wrong D. (1961) The over-socialized conception of man in modern sociology. American Sociological Review, 26(2): 183-193.

Young C. (2009) The emergence of sociology from political economy in the United States: 1890 to 1940. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences, 45(2): 91-116.