Article Information

THE DEVELOPMENT OF APPROACHES TO STUDYING MUSEUMS IN SOCIAL SCIENCES AND THE HUMANITIES

Alisa Maximova (alice.mcximove@gmail.com)

National Research University Higher School of Economics, Moscow, Russia

Citation: Maximova A. (2019) Razvitiye podkhodov k izucheniyu muzeyev v sotsial'nykh i gumanitarnykh naukakh [The development of approaches to studying museums in social sciences and the humanities]. Zhurnal sotsiologii i sotsialnoy antropologii [The Journal of Sociology and Social Anthropology], 22(2): 118-146 (in Russian). https://doi.org/10.31119/jssa.2019.22.2.5

Full Text (PDF)

Abstract. The paper aims at analyzing conceptual approaches in Museum Studies and their development. Definition of the museum, its functions and effects is not stable and unchallenged. Likewise, subject area of Museum studies is diverse in terms of disciplinary perspectives, premises, methods and approaches. Transformation in cultural life, as well as notorious cases and outstanding academic research works have influenced how museums are conceptualized. Literature analysis proves that in the field of Museum Studies the dominant approach regards power relations. It often uses concepts developed in the works of Michel Foucault. Power relations may be viewed in three ways: first, as the “civilizing” or disciplinary museum, second, as the representing museum, and third, as institute that reproduces inequality. However, the author argues that in the last two decades, there has been a tendency to focus on agency and microlevel. Consequently, there are research questions that emphasize actor and analysis of her activity, reception and reaction. These two alternative approaches to museum — power relations and macrostructures, on the one hand, and agency and everyday phenomena on the other, — are revealed in tree thematic subfields of research: museum materiality, knowledge construction, and communication. In conclusion, we present recent transformations in social science and museum practice and formulate new questions for future research.

Keywords: museum sociology, Michel Foucault, Museum Studies, audience, agency, interpretation, power.

Acknowledgements

The article was prepared within the framework of the HSE University Basic Research Program and funded by the Russian Academic Excellence Project '5-100'.

References

Anderson B. (2001) Voobrazhayemyye soobshchestva [Imagined communities]. Moscow: Kanon-Press-TS; Kuchkovo pole (in Russian).

Bennett T. (1988) The Exhibitionary Complex. Formations, 4: 73–102.

Bennett T. (1995) The Birth of the Museum: History, Theory, Politics. L.: Routledge.

Bourdieu P. (2005) Sotsiologiya sotsial'nogo prostranstva [Sociology of social space]. St. Petersburg: Aleteyya (in Russian).

Bourdieu P., Darbel A. (1991) The Love of Art. European Art Museums and their Public. Cambridge: Polity Press.

Cameron D. (1968) A Viewpoint: the Museum as a Communication System and Implications for Museum Education. Curator, 11(1): 33–40.

Christidou D., Diamantopoulou S. (2016) Seeing and Being Seen: The Multimodality of Museum Spectatorship. Museum & Society, 14(1): 12–32.

Clifford J. (1985) Objects and Selves. An Afterword. In: Stocking G. (ed.) Objects and Others. Objects and Others. Essays on Museums and Material Culture. Madison: The University of Wisconsin Press: 236–246.

Clifford J. (1997) Museums as Contact Zones. Routes: Travel and Translation in the Late Twentieth Century. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press: 188–219.

Clifford J., Marcus G. (eds.) (1986) Writing Culture: the Poetics and Politics of Ethnography. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1986.

Coffee K. (2007) Audience Research and the Museum Experience as Social Practice. Museum Management and Curatorship, 22(4): 377–389.

De Certeau M. (2013) Izobreteniye povsednevnosti [Practice of everyday life]. St. Petersburg: European University in Saint Petersburg Press (in Russian).

Dean M. (2016) Pravitel'nost': vlast' i pravleniye v sovremennykh obshchestvakh [Governmentality: Power And Rule In Modern Society]. Moscow: Delo (in Russian).

Dubin B. (2011) Arkhiv i vyskazyvaniye. K sotsiologii muzeya v sovremennoy Rossii [Archive and utterance: toward a sociology of museum in contemporary Russia]. Vestnik obshchestvennogo mneniya, 3(109): 106–109 (in Russian).

Dudley S. (ed.) (2012) Museum Objects: Experiencing the Properties of Things. L.: Routledge.

Duncan C. (1995) Civilizing Rituals: Inside Public Art Museums. N.Y.: Routledge.

Falk J., Dierking L. (2000) Learning from Museums: Visitor Experiences and the Making of Meaning. Walnut Creek, CA: AltaMira Press.

Foucault M. (1999) Nadzirat' i nakazyvat': Rozhdeniye tyur'my [Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison]. Moscow: Ad Marginem (in Russian).

Foucault M. (2004) Intellektualy i vlast' [Intellectuals and Power]. Part II. Moscow: Praxis (in Russian).

Foucault M. (2006) Drugiye prostranstva [Other Spaces]. In: Foucault M. Intellektualy i vlast' [Intellectuals and Power]. Part III. Moscow: Praxis: 191–204 (in Russian).

Fyfe G. (2006) Sociology and Social Aspects of Museums. In: S. Macdonald (ed.) A Companion to Museum Studies. Oxford: Blackwell Publ.

Geertz C. (1988) Works and Lives: The Anthropologist as Author. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1988.

Gilman B. (1916) Museum Fatigue. The Scientific Monthly, 2: 62–74.

Hetherington K. (1997) The Badlands of Modernity: Heterotopia and Social Ordering. L.: Psychology Press.

Hooper-Greenhill E. (1990) The Space of the Museum. Continuum, 1(3): 56–69.

Hooper-Greenhill E. (1992) Museums and the Shaping of Knowledge. L.: Routledge.

Hooper-Greenhill E. (1994) Museums and Their Visitors. L.: Routledge.

Huyssen A. (1995) Escape from Amnesia: Museum as Mass Medium. Twilight Memories. Marking Time in a Culture of Amnesia. L.: Routledge.

Jafari A., Taheri B., vom Lehn D. (2013) Cultural Consumption, Interactive Sociality, and the Museum. Journal of Marketing Management, 29(15–16): 1729–1752.

Kahn M. (1995) Heterotopic Dissonance in the Museum Representation of Pacific Island Cultures. American Anthropologist, 97(2): 324–338.

Kahn M. (2000) Not Really Pacific Voices: Politics of Representation in Collaborative Museum Exhibits. Museum Anthropology, 24(1): 57–74.

Kirchberg V. (2007) Thinking about “Scenes”: A New View of Visitors’ Influence on Museums. Curator, 50(2): 239–254.

Leahy H.R. (2012) Museum Bodies. The Politics and Practices of Visiting and Viewing. Farnham: Ashgate.

Lefebvre H. (2007) Rhythmanalysis: Space, Time, and Everyday Life. L.; N.Y.: Continuum.

Lord B. (2006) Foucault’s Museum: Difference, Representation, and Genealogy. Museum and Society. 4(1): 1–14.

Luebbe H. (2016) V nogu so vremenem. Sokrashchennoye prebyvaniye v nastoyashchem [In step with the time: shortened stay in the present]. Moscow: HSE Publishing House (in Russian).

Macdonald S. (1996) Theorizing Museums: an Introduction. In: Macdonald S., Fyfe G. (eds.) Theorizing Museums: Representing Identity and Diversity in a Changing World. Oxford: Blackwell Publ.

Macdonald S. (1997) The Museum as Mirror: Ethnographic Reflections. In: A. James, J. Hockey and A. Dawson (eds.) After Writing Culture. Epistemology and Praxis in Contemporary Anthropology. Routledge: 161–176.

Macdonald S. (2002) Behind the Scenes at the Science Museum. Oxford; N.Y.: Berg.

Macdonald S. (2013) Memorylands. Heritage and Identity in Europe Today. Oxford, N.Y.: Routledge.

Macleod S. (2005) Rethinking Museum Architecture: Towards a Site-Specific History of Production and Use. In: MacLeod S. (ed.) Reshaping Museum Space: Architecture, Design, Exhibitions. L.: Routledge.

Maksimova A. (2014) Kontseptual'nyye i metodologicheskiye voprosy izucheniya posetiteley muzeyev [Conceptual and methodological issues in visitor studies]. Sotsiologiya: Metodologiya, metody, matematicheskoye modelirovaniye [Sociology: methodology, methods, and mathematical modeling], 39: 157–188 (in Russian).

Marcus G., Fischer M. (1986) Anthropology as Cultural Critique. Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press.

McClellan A. (2004) Art and Its Public: Museum Studies at the Millenium. New Interventions in Art History. Oxford: Blackwell Publ.

Mumford L. (1961) The City in History. Its Origins, Its Transformations, and Its Prospects. N.Y.: Harcourt, Brace & World, Inc.

Pearce S. (1999) Museums of Anthropology or Museums as Anthropology? Anthropologica, 41(1): 25–34.

Prior N. (2011) Speed, Rhythm, and Time-Space: Museums and Cities. Space and Culture, 14: 200–201.

Rudenko N. (2015) Geterotopiya kak pereopisaniye: muzeynyye eksponaty, seti i praktiki [Heterotopy as redescription: museum exhibits, networks, and practices]. Sotsiologiya vlasti [Sociology of Power], 1: 181–195 (in Russian).

Samutina N., Zaporozhets O. (2014) Svoy sredi drugikh: antropologiya normy v prostranstve tsaritsynskogo parka [One among the Others: anthropology of norm in the space of Tsaritsyno park]. In: Samutina N., Stepanov B. (eds.) Tsaritsyno: attraktsion s istoriyey [Tsaritsyno: an attraction with history]. Moscow: Novoye literaturnoye obozreniye: 143–187 (in Russian).

Shmatko N. (2003) Analiz kul'turnogo proizvodstva P'yera Burd'ye [Analysis of Pierre Bourdieu’s cultural production]. Sotsiologicheskiye issledovaniya [Sociological Research], 8: 113–120 (in Russian).

Simon N. (2010) The Participatory Museum. Santa Cruz, CA: Museum 2.0.

Sokolov M., Sokolova N., Safonova M. (2016) Statusnyye kul'tury, biograficheskiye tsikly i pokolencheskiye izmeneniya v literaturnykh vkusakh chitateley peterburgskikh bibliotek [Status cultures, biographic cycles, and generational changes in literary tastes]. Zhurnal sotsiologii i sotsial'noy antropologii [The Journal of Sociology and Social Anthropology], 3(86): 116–135 (in Russian).

Stocking G. (1985) Objects and Others. Essays on Museums and Material Culture. Madison: The University of Wisconsin Press.

Urry J. (1996) How Societies Remember the Past. In: Macdonald S., Fyfe G. (eds.) Theorizing Museums: Representing Identity and Diversity in a Changing World. Oxford: Blackwell Publ.

Vergo P. (1989) New Museology. L.: Reaktion Books.

Wallach A., Duncan C. (1978) The Museum of Modern Art as Late Capitalist Ritual: an Iconographic Analysis. Marxist Perspectives, 4.

Wallach A., Duncan C. (1980) The Universal Survey Museum. Art History, 3(4): 448–469.

Warner W. L. (2000) Zhivyye i mertvyye [The living and the dead]. Moscow, St. Petersburg: Universitetskaya kniga [University Book] (in Russian).

Weintraub J. (1997) The Theory and Politics of the Public/Private Distinction. In: Weintraub J., Kumar K. (eds.) Public and Private in Thought and Practice. Perspective on a Grand Dichotomy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Wood E., Latham K. (2014) The Objects of Experience: Transforming Visitor-Object Encounters in Museums. Walnut Creek, CA: Left Coast Press, Inc.

Yaneva A. (2003a) Chalk Steps on the Museum Floor: The `Pulses' of objects in an art installation. Journal of Material Culture, 8(2): 169–188.

Yaneva A. (2003b) When a Bus Met a Museum: Following Artists, Curators and Workers in Art Installation. Museum and Society, 1(3): 116–131.

Zukin S. (2015) Kul'tury gorodov [The cultures of cities]. Moscow: Novoye literaturnoye obozreniye (in Russian).