Article Information


Galina Karpova (

Central European University, Budapest, Hungary

Citation: Karpova G. (2021) Vliyaniye kollektivnoy pamyati na potrebitel'skiye praktiki: keys rayona Tushino (Moskva) [The influence of collective memory on consumption practices: the case of Tushino district (Moscow)]. Zhurnal sotsiologii i sotsialnoy antropologii [The Journal of Sociology and Social Anthropology], 24(1): 138–167 (in Russian).

Annotation. The article is devoted to the study of ongoing transformations of consumer practices among old Tushino residents in connection with changes of lifestyle and type of labor in the area. As a Moscow district, Tushino was one of the centers of aviation, army and civil industries during Soviet years. In particular, workers of Tushino mechanical factory, founded in 1932, in cooperation with «Molniya» institute researchers have constructed and launched «Buran» spacecraft in 1988. Since the beginning of the 2000s, Tushino factories started fading and ceased to function completely by 2013, giving up their space for rent to commercial companies. How do collective memory and ex-factory infrastructure influence on old residents’ consumer behavior in the district? In my work, I continue the existing project "Past and present of working-class districts", with the focus on the consumer practices in the context of district changes. During the study, 9 semi-formal interviews with old Tushino residents were conducted, with former employees of the Tushino mechanical factory and «Molniya» enterprise, as well as with old residents who were not involved in factory life. Informants were asked about their personal history of living in Tushino, views on current changes and consumer habits. Based on the analysis of the interview, I present three consumer strategies for responding to district transformations shared among residents. The first strategy is based on individual consumer resistance and unites residents who resist urban transformations by nostalgic consumption and the commitment to shops, department stores and places of cultural consumption that have barely changed from Soviet times. People from this category closely maintain social connections with other members of their community. The second group includes old-timers who resist by cooperating with the local authorities as activists, volunteers and councilors of municipal deputies. By influencing on political initiatives on transformation of the area and promoting ideas of preserving factory infrastructure, activists indirectly express consumer resistance. The third group represents residents who do not demonstrate signs of resistance. The study partially confirms the assumption that resistance to post-industrial transformations is manifested in the consumer behavior of old Tushino residents.

Keywords: territorial identity, collective memory, consumption practices, gentrification, ex-factory area, industrial area.


Amin A., Thrift N. (2002) Cities: reimagining the urban. Cambridge: Polity Press.

Baudrillard J. (2006) Obshchestvo potrebleniya. Ego mify i struktury. [The Consumer Society: Myths and Structures]. Moscow: Kul'turnaya revolyuciya. Respublika (in Russian).

Burgess E. (2000) Rost goroda: Vvedenie v issledovatel'skij proekt [The Growth of the City: An introduction to a research project]. Social'nye i gumanitarnye nauki za rubezhom. Ser. 11. Sociologiya [Social and humanitarian sciences abroad. Ser. 11. Sociology], 4: 122–136 (in Russian).

Burstin D. (1993) Soobshchestva potrebleniya [Consumption communities]. Thesis, 3: 231–254 (in Russian).

Clarke D. (2002) Potreblenie i gorod, sovremennost' i postsovremennost' [Consumption and city, modernity and post-modernity]. Logos. 34(3) [ ] (in Russian).

Eyerman R. (2004) The Past in the Present: Culture and the Transmission of Memory. Acta Sociologica, 47(2): 159–169.

Gotham K. (2001) Urban Redevelopment, Past and Present. In: Critical Perspectives on Urban Redevelopment. Vol. 6. Bingley: Emerald Group Publishing Limited: 1–31.

Halbwachs M. (2005) Kollektivnaya i istoricheskaya pamyat' [On collective and historical memory]. Neprikosnovennyj zapas, 40–41 (in Russian).

Harvey D. (2008) Pravo na gorod [Right to the city]. Logos, 3, pp. 80–94 (in Russian).

Holbrook M., Schindler R. (2003) Nostalgic bonding: Exploring the role of nostalgia in the consumption experience. Journal of Consumer Behavior, 3(2): 107–127.

Jacobs J. (2011) Zhizn' i smert' bol'shih amerikanskih gorodov [The Death and Life of Great American Cities]. Moscow: Novoe izdatel'stvo (in Russian).

Kansteiner W. (2002) Finding Meaning in Memory: A Methodological Critique of Collective Memory Studies. History and Theory, 41(2): 179–197.

Khokhlova A. (2011) Gorodskie publichnye mesta kak ploshchadki kul'turnogo proizvodstva i potrebleniya [Urban public places as sites of cultural production and consumption]. Zhurnal sotsiologii i sotsialnoy antropologii [The Journal of Sociology and Social Anthropology], 14(5): 182–191 (in Russian).

Lefebvre H. (2015) Proizvodstvo prostranstva [The production of space]. Moscow: Strelka Press (in Russian).

Lynch K. (1982) Obraz goroda [The image of the city]. Moscow: Strojizdat (in Russian).

Makarova E. (2010) Postindustrializm, dzhentrifikaciya i transformaciya gorodskogo prostranstva v sovremennoj Moskve. [Post-industrialism, gentrification and transformation of urban space in modern Moscow]. Neprikosnovennyj zapas, 2(70): 150–152 (in Russian).

Rozhdestvenskaya E. (2017) Reprezentaciya kul'turnoj travmy: muzeefikaciya holokosta. [The representation of cultural trauma: the museumification of the Holocaust]. Logos, 27(5): 87–132 (in Russian).

Sassen S. (2007) Global'nyj gorod: teoriya i real'nost' [Global city: theory and reality]. Pod red. N.A. Sluki. Moscow: Avanglion: 9–27 (in Russian).

Shtompka P. (2001) Social'noe izmenenie kak travma [The social change as trauma]. Sociologicheskie issledovaniya [Sociological research], 1: 6–16 (in Russian).

Simmel G. (2002) Bol'shie goroda i duhovnaya zhizn' [The Metropolis and Mental Life], Logos, 3–4 [ ] (in Russian).

Smelser N. (2001) Psychological Trauma and Cultural Trauma. In: Alexander J., Eyerman R., Giesen B., Smelser N., Sztompka P. Cultural Trauma and Collective Identity. Berkeley; Los Angeles; London: University of California Press: 31–59.

Smith N. (2002) New globalism, new urbanism: gentrification as global urban strategy. Antipode, 34(3): 427–450.

Strel'nikova A. (2012) «Mesta pamyati» v gorodskom prostranstve [«Places of memory» in urban space]. Vestnik RGGU. Seriya: Filosofiya. Sociologiya. Iskusstvovedenie [RSUH Bulletin. Series: Philosophy. Sociology. Art], 2: 231–238 (in Russian).

Strelnikova A. (2016) Politika pamyati kak simvolicheskaya reinterpretaciya proshlogo (na primere pamyatnika «Rabochij i kolhoznica») [The politics of memory as a symbolic reinterpretation of the past (on the example of the monument «Worker and collective farmer»). In: XVI Aprel'skaya mezhdunarodnaya nauchnaya konferenciya po problemam razvitiya ekonomiki i obshchestva: v 4 kn. [XVI April international scientific conference on economic and social development]. Kn. 2. Moscow: Izdatel'skij dom NIU VSHE: 253–258 (in Russian).

Strelnikova A. (2018) Smysly zhizni, ukorenennye v prostranstve: nostal'gicheskaya identichnost' zhitelej "zavodskih" rajonov [Meanings of life rooted in space: the nostalgic identity of "factory" districts’ residents]. In: Smysly zhizni rossijskoj intelligencii [The meaning of life of the Russian intelligentsia]. Moscow: RGGU: 275–280 (in Russian).

Strelnikova A. (2018) Sud'ba Burana v strukture territorial'noj identichnosti rajona Tushino [«Buran» role in territorial identity of Tushino district]. Interakciya. Interv'yu. Interpretaciya. [Interaction. Interview. Interpretation], 16: 60–68 (in Russian).

Strelnikova A.V (2018) Proshloe i nastoyashchee rabochih rajonov [Past and present of working districts] [ ] (accessed: 20.04.2020) (in Russian).

Sutton D. (2008) A Tale of Easter Ovens: Food and Collective Memory Social Research, 75(1), Collective Memory and Collective Identity: 157–180.

Toennis F. (2002) Obshchnost' i obshchestvo [Community and society]. St. Petersburg: Vladimir Dal' (in Russian).

Urri J. (2012) Mobil'nosti [Mobility]. Moscow: Praksis (in Russian).

Vikeri D. (2009) Vozrozhdenie gorodskih prostranstv posredstvom kul'turnyh proektov — sintez social'noj, kul'turnoj i gorodskoj politiki [Urban renewal through cultural projects –– a synthesis of social, cultural and urban policy]. Vizual'naya antropologiya: gorodskie karty pamyati. Moscow: Variant; CSPSR: 205–235 (in Russian).

Wertsch J. (2008) Collective Memory and Narrative Templates. Social Research, 75(1), Collective Memory and Collective Identity: 133–156.

Wirth L. (2005) Getto [Ghetto]. In: Wirth L. Izbrannye raboty po sociologii: Sbornik perevodov [Selected works in sociology]. Moscow: INION (in Russian).

Wirth L. (2005) Urbanizm kak obraz zhizni [Urbanism as a way of life] In: Wirth L. Izbrannye raboty po sociologii: Sbornik perevodov [Selected works in sociology]. Moscow: INION (in Russian).

Zhidkova E. (2014) Gorodskaya okraina: ot geroizacii «cheloveka truda» do poiska novyh smyslov. [Urban outskirts: from the heroization of the labor man to the search for new meanings]. Labirint. Zhurnal social'no-gumanitarnyh issledovanij [Labirint. Journal of social and humanitarian research], 1: 57–63 (in Russian).

Zorbo H. (2004) Zolotoj Bereg i trushchoby [The gold coast and the Slum]. Social'nye i gumanitarnye nauki za rubezhom. Ser. 11. Sociologiya [Social and humanitarian sciences abroad. Ser. 11. Sociology], 3: 115–154; 4: 140–178 (in Russian).