Article Information


Elena Bogomiagkova (, Kirill Ivashchenko

Saint Petersburg University, Saint Petersburg, Russia

Citation: Bogomiagkova E., Ivashchenko K. (2019) Problema podderzhaniya sotsial'nogo poryadka v situatsii organizatsionnykh izmeneniy (na primere meditsinskogo soobshchestva) [Maintaining social order in a situation of organizational changes (on the example of a medical community)]. Zhurnal sotsiologii i sotsialnoy antropologii [The Journal of Sociology and Social Anthropology], 22(1): 66–89 (in Russian).

Full Text (PDF)

Abstract. This article approaches the issue of maintaining social order in terms of organizational changes. The department of the military medical institution has been used as an example. Having faced the necessity to be divided into two parts — one moved to the civil hospital and the other to another location within the same institution — the study medical community experienced a ‘breakdown’ of social order. The research interest was focused on the subculture of the professional group as well as on the outcomes of this ‘breakdown’ and methods of restoration used by medical professionals in their new work environment. This research is based on a number of sociological and anthropological theories of organizational and professional cultures, and on Garfinkel’s concept of social order revisited by A. Korbut. Empirical base consists of interviews with 9 medical professionals before and after the organizational changes. This study draws important conclusions about the specific nature of the study occupational community. When the informants described workplace, the commonly used the metaphorical image of ‘home’. The informants mentioned different behavioral habits among colleagues, which cannot be reflected on or logically explained, and which turned out to be explicit due to the organizational changes. The main difference between the new workplace and the old one lies in transition from the ‘everyday life’ mode to the ‘awareness’ mode, meaning that the routine actions and workflow lost their ‘naturalness’ and ’normality’. This included the following: 1) maintaining connections with other departments of the Academy and interpersonal relationships between colleagues; 2) holding conferences on the everyday basis and paying attention to one’s workplace and work environment; 3) holding onto some in-group beliefs and sticking to certain work traditions and rituals; 4) restoring conventional working practices. Thus, we draw conclusion that, in their everyday routine, professionals follow not external or imposed norms (such as medical education, regulations and protocols), but rather they rely on situational and local ‘normality’ of their colleagues’ behavior, which provides predictability and mutual understanding and, as a result, constitutes social order.

Keywords: Occupational community, medical community, social order, medical culture, professional culture, interview.


Ageeva N.A. (2013) Professionalnaya kultura kak nravstvennyy imperativ deyatelnosti vracha [Professional culture as moral imperative of doctor's activity]. Gumanitarnye i socialnye nauki [Humanities and social Sciences], 6: 77–86 (in Russian).

Butvilovskij A.V., Gilevskij A.V., Butvilovskij V.E., Karmalkova I.S. (2013) Professional`naya medicinskaya kultura [Professional medical culture]. Voennaya medicina [Military medicine], 4: 6–7 (in Russian).

Callen J.L., Braithwaite J., Westbrook J.I. (2009) The Importance of Medical and Nursing Sub-cultures in the Implementation of Clinical Information Systems. Methods of Information in Medicine, 48(2): 196–202.

Chirikova A. (2013) Vrachi kak professional`naya gruppa: vosproizvodstvo i podderzhanie vrachebnogo professionalizma [Physicians as a Professional Group: Production and Maintaining of Medical Professionalis]. Zhurnal issledovaniy sotsialnoy politiki [The Journal of Social Policy Studies], 3: 307–320 (in Russian).

Correia T. (2017) Doctors’ Reflexivity in Hospital Organisations: The Nexus between Institutional and Behavioural Dynamics in the Sociology of Professions. Current Sociology, 65(7): 1050–1069.

Dudina V., Korobenkova M. (2011) Formalnye normy` i neformalnye praktiki v rabote personala vyezdnykh brigad skoroj medicinskoj pomoshchi [Formal rules and informal practices in the field of medical care]. Zhurnal sotsiologii i sotsialnoy antropologii [The Journal of sociology and social anthropology], 14(2): 165–181(in Russian).

Gadea Ch. (2011) Sociologiya professij i sociologiya professionalnykh grupp. Za izmenenie perspektivy [Sociology of professions and sociology of professional groups. For a change of perspective]. In: Romanov P., Iarskaia-Smirnova E. (eds.) Antropologiya professiy, ili postoronnim vkhod razreshen [Anthropology of professions, or the stranger’s input is permitted], Moscow: OOO «Variant»»: 15–34 (in Russian).

Garfinkel G. (2007) Izuchenie rutinnykh osnov povsednevnykh deystviy [The study of the foundations of routine activities of daily living]. In: G. Garfinkel. Issledovaniya po etnometodologii [Studies in ethnomethodology]. St. Petersburg: Piter (in Russian).

Gokce B., Guney S., Katrinli A. (2014) Does Doctors’ Perception of Hospital Leadership Style and Organizational Culture Influence their Organizational Commitment? Social Behavior and Personality, 42(9): 1549–1561.

Hughes E. (2009) Izgotovlenie vracha: formulirovka idej i problem [The Making of a Physician: General Statement of Ideas and Problems]. Zhurnal issledovaniy sotsialnoy politiki [The Journal of Social Policy Studies], 3: 313–326 (in Russian).

Hughes E. (2012) Professii [Professions]. In: Romanov P., Iarskaya-Smirnova E. (eds.) Antropologiya professiy: granitsy zanyatosti v epokhu nestabilnosti [Anthropology of professions: boundaries of employment in an era of instability], Moscow: OOO «Variant»: 31–58 (in Russian).

Iarskaia-Smirnova E., Romanov P. (2008) «Skrytoe znanie» v folklore professionalnykh grupp [«Hidden knowledge» in folklore of professional groups]. In: Kargin A., Kostina A. (eds.) Folklor malykh socialnykh grupp: traditsii i sovremennost [Folklore of small social groups: traditions and modernity], Moscow: Gosudarstvennyj respublikanskij centr russkogo folklora: 33–50 (in Russian).

Korbut A.M. (2013) Kontsepciya konstitutivnogo poryadka v etnometodologii [The conception of constitutive order in ethnomethodology]. Zhurnal sotsiologii i sotsialnoy antropologii [The Journal of sociology and social anthropology], 16(2): 65–82 (in Russian).

Maanen V.J., Barley S.R. (1984) Occupational Communities: Culture and Control in Organizations. Research in Organizational Behavior. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press, 6: 287–365.

Meterko M., Mohr D.C., Young G.J. (2004) Teamwork Culture and Patient Satisfaction in Hospitals. Medical Care, 42(5): 492–498.

Mol A. (2015) Mnozhestvennoye telo [The Body Multiple]. Sotsiologiya vlasti [Sociology of Power], 1: 232–247 (in Russian).

Morgan Ph.I., Ogbonna E. (2008) Subcultural Dynamics in Transformation: A Multi-perspective Study of Healthcare Professionals. Human Relations, 61(1): 39–65.

Odom R.Y., Boxx W.R., Dunn M.G. (1990) Organizational Cultures, Commitment, Satisfaction, and Cohesion. Public Productivity & Management Review, 14(2): 157–169.

Paeeva A. (2014) Professionalnaya kultura vracha: osobennosti transformatsii kontrolya professionalnoy deyatelnosti [Professional culture of a doctor: transformation of supervision of professional activities]. Filosofsko-kulturologicheskie idei akademika V.S. Styopina v svete sovremennykh socialnykh transformatsiy [Philosophical and cultural ideas by academician V.S. Stepin in the light of modern social transformations]: 116–119 (in Russian).

Romanov P.V., Iarskaia-Smirnova E.R. (2008) Mir professiy kak pole antropologicheskikh issledovaniy [The world of professions as a field of anthropological research]. Etnograficheskoye obozreniye [The Ethnographic Review], 5: 3–17 (in Russian).

Romanov P.V., Iarskaia-Smirnova E.R. (2009) Mir professiy: peresmotr analiticheskikh perspektiv [World of professions: revision of analytical perspectives]. Sotsiologicheskoe obozreniye [Sociological review], 8: 25–35 (in Russian).

Sabri H.M. (2004) Socio-Cultural Values and Organizational Culture. Journal of Transnational Management Development, 9(2): 123 — 145.

Schepanskaya T. (2011) Simvolizaciya povsednevnosti i neformalnyy kontrol v professionalnom soobshchestve [Symbolizing of everyday life and informal control in the professional community]. In: Romanov P., Iarskaia-Smirnova E. (eds.) Antropologiya professiy, ili postoronnim vkhod razreshen [Anthropology of professions, or the stranger’s input is permitted], Moscow: OOO «Variant»»: 85–113 (in Russian).

Simonova O., Yadrova E. (2013) Soobshhestvo srednikh meditsinskikh sotrudnikov v oblasti kardiokhirurgii: sotsiologicheskiy analiz emotsionalnogo truda [Community of mid-level medical staff in the field of cardiac surgery: sociological analysis of emotional labor]. In: Romanov P., Iarskaya-Smirnova E. (eds.) Professii sotsialnogo gosudarstva [The professions of the welfare state], Moscow: OOO «Variant»: 91–116 (in Russian).

Strauss A., Schazman L., Ehrlich D., Bucher R. and Sabshin M. (1963) The hospital and its negotiated order. In: Friedson E. (ed.) The hospital in modern society. New York: Macmillan: 73–130.

Szeptuch A. (2016) The measurement of organizational culture in healthcare organizations. E-MENTOR, 3: 60–67.

Zharova M.N. (2011) Medicinskaya kul`tura medicinskogo obshhestva [Medical culture of medical society]. Zhurnal GlavVrach [Journal of the Physician], 6: 87–95 (in Russian).